Baseball Bargains Staff Picks

The staff at Baseball Bargains is comprised of former High School, College and Independent League Players who have expert knowledge in the equipment we sell.

We have polled the educated staff at Baseball Bargains to comprise a list of the top five Adult catchers mitts available for the 2025 season. Here are the rankings and the reasons why our staff feels they are the best catchers mitts available this year.

#1 - Allstar CM3000 Catchers Mitts

The Allstar CM3000 glove is for the serios catcher.  This Pro elite series  of catchers mitts have been tops in the industry for decades.  The durability, comfort and feel are what make these gloves the top choice for MLB, College and High School catchers.  The CM300 gloves are offered in  multiple sizes and color schemes to get every catcher a glove that looks, fits, and feels great.  Check out the full selection here:  CM3000 Catchers Mitts

#2 - Easton Flagship 33.5 inch Catchers Mitt

The Easton Flagship is a surprise to be this high on the list.  Typically Easton gloves are solid choices but don't necessarily stand out  like their Flagship series does.  The catchers mitt has a comfortable and durable feel that would compare to the Rawlings Heart of the Hide and Wilson A2000 models. But, the reason this model is so high on the list is the price tag.  You can purchase 2 of these gloves for the price of the HOH and A2000 and still have enough money to fill you gas tank. Check out the staff choice as Bargain of the Year here: Easton Flagship Catchers Mitt

#3 - Wilson A2000 M23 33.5 inch Baseball Catchers Mitt

You can never go wrong with an A2000 glove.  The leather, craftsmanship and durability are what has made the A2000 a perennial top performing glove for decades.  This 33.5 inch catchers mitt is a prime example of the design and craftsmanship that make the A2000 series so popular.  This A2000 catchers mitt is available in three different looks this year. Check them out and pick you favorite here:  Wilson A2000 M23 Catchers Mitt

#4 - Rawlings Heart of the Hide Yadier Molina 34 inch Catchers Mitt PRORYM4C

Rawlings is the one company that is synonymous with baseball gloves.  They too, like Wilson, have been a top brand in the industry for over a century.  The main reason why the Yadier Molina model fell to number four is because of price and size.  The price is what you typically have to pay for quality, but the size  - 34 inches is for the players with larger hands and can control a mitt of this size.  As far as the leather, craftsmanship and durability goes, you can never go wrong with a Heart of the Hide model from Rawlings.  This catchers mitt looks and feels great.  Check it out on out website here: Rawlings Heart of the Hide 34 inch Catchers Mitt

#5 - Mizuno MVP Prime GXC50PB4 34 inch Catchers Mitt

Mizuno gloves are known as the "get more than you paid for models".   The price you pay for a quality glove from Mizuno is a fraction of that of comparable gloves form the likes  of Wilson and Rawlings.  The Mizuno MVP Prime series has been  a great performer for the Mizuno brand for almost 20 years. The reason why is the combination of the durable feel and the quick break of the leather.  The price, fit and feel are very similar to that of the Easton Flagship.  The Flagship model has a more appealing look with the chocolate brown leather versus the black leather used in the MVP Prime model.  Check out the look and the great price of the Mizuno MVP Prime model here:  Mizuno MVP Prime Catchers Mitt

We hope this blog was informative and helpful to you.  By no means are we saying that the other gloves we carry are not top of the line catchers mitts.  They best catchers mitt, or the right catchers glove for a player varies from player to player.  Factors to consider are frequency of play, budget,  Size, durability, personal preference, look and feel. All of these are no the same for every player.  That is why Baseball Bargains offers such a variety, so each player can find the right model for themselves.  

Feel free to ask for help in choosing the best adult catchers mitt model for you by contacting our experienced and educated staff at: customerservice@BaseballBargains.com