How to Break In a New Baseball Glove: Step-by-Step Guide

July 21, 2025

There’s nothing quite like the feel of a brand-new baseball glove—stiff leather, fresh smell, and the promise of seasons to come. But before it becomes your go-to gamer, you've got some work to do. A new glove won’t be game-ready right out of the box—it needs to be broken in properly to shape it to your hand, improve flexibility, and form that perfect pocket.

Here’s your complete step-by-step guide on how to break in a new baseball glove the right way.

Step 1: Choose the Right Glove for Your Position

Before breaking it in, make sure your glove is the right fit for your position and hand size. Infielders typically go for smaller, lighter gloves for quick transfers, while outfielders use deeper pockets for snagging fly balls. Catchers and pitchers need position-specific mitts. Choose quality leather—it breaks in better and lasts longer.

Step 2: Soften the Leather (Without Ruining It)

To start the break-in process, soften the leather just enough to make it more pliable without damaging it.

Do:

Use a glove conditioner or oil specifically made for baseball gloves.
Apply a small amount with a clean cloth or your fingers to the pocket, heel, and laces.
Let it sit overnight to soak in.

Don’t:

Overdo it with oil (too much can make the leather heavy and soggy).
Use household oils or shaving cream (these can damage the glove long-term).

Step 3: Shape the Pocket

Shaping the pocket is one of the most important parts of the process. You want the glove to close around the ball naturally.

Try These Methods:

Play catch: The best way to form a glove is using it. Even short sessions will help the leather flex and mold.
Use a mallet: Pound the pocket with a glove mallet or a baseball wrapped in a sock to mimic ball impact.
Wrap it up: Place a ball in the pocket, fold the glove naturally, and tie it closed with a belt, shoelace, or glove wrap overnight.

Step 4: Flex the Fingers and Work the Laces

Gently bend the fingers back and forth to encourage flexibility. Tug on the laces just a little to make sure they’re not overly tight from the factory.

Pro tip: Don’t try to "speed things up" with ovens or microwaves—these can ruin your glove permanently.

Step 5: Use It Consistently

There’s no shortcut for a glove that fits like, well, a glove. The more you use it, the more it will mold to your hand and playing style. Bring it to practice, warm-ups, or even just toss a ball into it while watching TV.

Bonus Tips:

Keep it clean and dry. Moisture and dirt can wear down leather over time.
Store it properly. Keep it in a cool, dry place with a ball in the pocket to hold its shape.
Reapply conditioner sparingly. A little every few months will keep the leather healthy.

Final Thoughts

Breaking in a glove is a personal process. Some players like it a little stiffer, others want it super soft. Either way, patience and consistency are key. Take the time to break it in the right way, and you’ll end up with a glove that fits like an extension of your hand—ready for big plays and big moments.

Want more gear tips and baseball know-how? Check out our latest posts or explore our full lineup of performance-ready gloves to find your perfect fit.